Which boy: the nice one or the goodhearted one?

Hi everybody! ummm..I've'e been havin a lot of trouble with this and im hoping somebody can help m eout a lil. ok. I've'e been dating this boy for the past 3 and a half years but before dating him I was dating a boy I was with since elementry school. but...

the boy from elementry school moved away. so I stayed with the boy I was with for the 3 and a half years. and now HES BACK! and he wants me bac and he treats me soo much better then the other boy does. but the other boy just knows me soo well we've became one,equal. yakno. we have bin thru soo much crys laughs sex everythin. he was my 1st and now that my old elementry boyfriend is bac I dont know what 2 do and I dont want to make the wrong desicion. HELLPPP..!!

ASK THEM BOTH QUESTIONS ABOUT YOU WHO EVER GET THEM WRITE HE'S THE ONE FOR you THE GUY FROM ELEMENTARY MIGHT JUST BE trying TO GET A BOOTIE CALL SO LET ME NO WHAT GOES DOWN

You have to follow your heart, maria.

Puppy love is what we call it in Spain (referring to your elementary school boyfriend). But if you're elementary school boyfriend treats you good, and respects you, and really wants to be with you, he will show it.

I know exactly what you are talking about when you say that you and your boyfriend now are like one. Pick the one you'd like to have for a friend forever, and one that you'd like to be sexual with, and maybe be married to forever. Maybe you don't want to be with one of them forever, so pick the other one. It may be confusing but funmail me if I can help any more.

if the one from elemtary school treats you better and you love him I think you should be with him.