Welcome!


Join 124,064 members on FunAdvice to ask questions, share advice, photos and make new friends today.
FunAdvice RSS for this page:
Rss_feed

Would you sacrifice one person for a family?

Beanie? Asked by xxjulixx 5 months ago, 5 answers.

So you are on a bridge with another person standing next to you. Then you look down and there is a family of 3, crossing some railroad tracks. And coincidently, here comes a train.

How do you save the three people? Well here's the catch:
If you were to...

push the person next to you, he could stop the train and you could be the savior of 3 people.

Would you push the man over and save the family? If not then what would you do?

If this sounds familiar then you should know that this came from a vid. =p

Answered by stephanief987 on May 27, 2008, 07:10PM
| 11436 answers.
Advisor-small

I don't think pushing someone in front of a train is going to completely stop the train that fast and in time to save the family. Unless the person being pushed is the hulk, lol.

Answered by saucybaby on May 27, 2008, 07:31PM
| 1641 answers.
Advisor-small

I'd be too shocked to move

Answered by xxjulixx on May 28, 2008, 05:19PM
| 834 answers.

Pushing over a person could do it. Better? Because the web said so, so please answer without saying:

"I need to be convinced that the train will stop by one person."

Thank you!

Answered by kylin15 on Jun 02, 2008, 07:15PM
| 51 answers.

shout and dont push! save them all

Answered by kcblayer on Jun 02, 2008, 08:39PM
| 86 answers.

hmmm depending on if that one person was a believer in christ our savior and the family wasn't. If the family happened to all be believers and the person that I would push was NOT a believer than I would let the family die. But if the family members were not believers and the person that I would push WAS than I would push him. And if none of them were believers than I would jump- and you are going to ask well how do I know? I wouldn't know so I would jump to save to believers or the non believers because I would rather have believers live than a non-believer die. This is just me. I believe that we all have a purpose and if my one duty in life that GOD gave me was to die so those 4 people could live than I would have to do it. When god calls you have to answer.

god bless

| 0 of 1 thought this was helpful

Answer this Question: "Would you sacrifice one person for a family?"

Your Answer: HTML is not allowed.


Back to top

Popular questions related to Would you sacrifice one person for a family?