Do aborted babies have ghosts... :s

Asked by fau 23 days ago, 48 answers.

Really random thought but anyway, I'm an atheist so I don't believe in ghosts. But to the people that do, do you believe that when a baby is aborted, it has a ghost? I don't even know how that entered my head. Probably sound dead stupid but oh well....

Views? :]

Answered by colethky on Nov 25, 2008, 09:17PM
2187 answers
Advisor-small

You know this whole thing has gotten out of hand...

I had a miscarriage when I was15, I was 5 months pregnant and to this day I still mourn for my child that I lost.

I am pro-choice and it is a fact that while a baby is inside of their mothers womb it is called a fetus...plain and simple, it's fact. You can argue all you want about whether abortion is murder or not but you can't change the facts. A pregnant woman carries a fetus...yes most people call it a baby and I don't see anything wrong with that...I did when I was pregnant but it is still a fetus.

And there is a big difference between the women that miscarry and the women that get abortions...the women that miscarry want their babies, that is why they call them babies that is why nobody denies them their right to grieve. When I lost my child I thought it was the end of the world...I got past it and now have 3 beautiful children and there is not a day that goes by when I don't think about my baby. But I would never deny a woman the right to do what she wants with her own body. Why should I have any say in that?

1 person thought this was helpful

Answered by mandyloo on Nov 25, 2008, 01:25PM
4016 answers
Advisor-small

Wow, I almost find it hilarious that people think that aborted fetuses have ghost/souls/etc.

I believe the complete opposite of that.

0 people thought this was helpful

Answered by fungirl1990 on Nov 25, 2008, 01:25PM
41 answers

Ummm I guess they could ...I belieeve in ghost but I aint never seen one in real life or pictures...but I guess its just like any other human being who dies and has a ghost

Answered by blerggher on Nov 25, 2008, 01:25PM
806 answers

good quesiton

Answered by hollistercazed on Nov 25, 2008, 01:26PM
172 answers

nope! if they were never born or anything then no. im wicken and I would know!!!

Answered by carjon011208 on Nov 25, 2008, 01:29PM
491 answers

if they were never born it shouldn't matter, they were still alive, they had a beating heart at some point, they were developing to be a human one day and when you get an abortion you are stopping a beating heart, which is murder...so they should... well not ghost per se, but they have souls... I would hope.

Answered by mandyloo on Nov 25, 2008, 01:33PM
4016 answers
Advisor-small

It's not murder!

If it were murder, abortions would be illegal and the mother's who got them would be trialed for murder.
Abortions are simply terminating an unwanted or potentially harmful pregnancy. It is used for many reason's and for you to judge a woman who has gotten one and call her a murderer is judgemental and offensive.

1 person thought this was helpful

Answered by sexci_baby08 on Nov 25, 2008, 01:34PM
189 answers

wow thats creepy I've never even thought about it..but they probably could since they are alive and all untill they get murdered

Answered by fungirl1990 on Nov 25, 2008, 01:36PM
41 answers

I think it is murder because it has a life ... you may npt b able to c it till its born but it has a heartbeat amd breaths so it has a life so I think its classified as murder

Answered by mandyloo on Nov 25, 2008, 01:37PM
4016 answers
Advisor-small

You need to study biology a little more - it does not breathe until it's born. It's not a baby until it's born - it's a fetus. A fetus that knows nothing of life. It is NOT murder.

1 person thought this was helpful

Answered by harleyrider on Nov 25, 2008, 02:15PM
1100 answers

Mandyloo, you just need to let people have there own opinion sometimes. Not everyone is going to agree with you.

My answer is goes to heaven. Ghost are another story.

Answered by mandyloo on Nov 25, 2008, 02:18PM
4016 answers
Advisor-small

I didn't say that they have to agree with me, I'm allowed to speak my opinion just as they are allowed to speak theirs.

I simply stated that they need to study their biology a little bit more. In order to breathe, they would have to be outside the womb. A fetus does not breathe in the womb, it takes it's first breath when it is born.

Answered by katieliddle233 on Nov 25, 2008, 02:24PM
184 answers

I aggree with mandyloo, I don't believe they have ghosts tbh.
I don't even believe ghosts exist tbh, it all seems a bit ridiculous.

But I have to admit, I do get a laugh out of watching 'most haunted'. Has me laughing when theyre all screaming 'WHAT'S THAT NOISE?' when tbh no-one at home heard anything.

It's great happy

Answered by harleyrider on Nov 25, 2008, 02:24PM
1100 answers

Yes, but to them It is a child and it is murder
and no matter what anyone says to them they are going to feel the same,
just as you are passionate about your beleifs
but I would not keep trying to tell you that you are wrong just because you don't agree with me.

Answered by mandyloo on Nov 25, 2008, 02:27PM
4016 answers
Advisor-small

Harleyrider,

Get over it. You calling me out all the time, does nothing positve and nothing good. I am allowed my opinion and am allowed to say it. I can say that calling it murder is wrong, because that's what I honesly believe.
If you don't like my opinions so much, then ignore them. There are plenty of other people on this site that agree with me, and plenty of people who don't. We are all allowed our own opinions and the right to debate them.

Answered by colethky on Nov 25, 2008, 02:36PM
2187 answers
Advisor-small

I for one agree with mandyloo...

Abortion is not murder. The fetus does not breathe and does not even have a heartbeat for the first couple of weeks.

As for the question...I don't think that they would have a ghost because I don't believe that they have a soul until they are born. You can argue with me all you want but that is my opinion.

Answered by mandyloo on Nov 25, 2008, 02:41PM
4016 answers
Advisor-small

Amblessed - learn your facts. You are spewing out false information.

If you kill a pregnant woman - you are NOT charged with 2 murders, unless the woman is in her third trimester. That is also a NEW law and just came around.

Abortions are NOT done in the third trimester anyways. So that point is not very valid.

Answered by mandyloo on Nov 25, 2008, 02:44PM
4016 answers
Advisor-small

I think that every pro-life person should have to adopt a crack baby, take care of it for a few months, then watch it die from the mother's drug abuse in the end.

Then let's see how they feel about abortions.

Answered by jester_x on Nov 25, 2008, 02:48PM
803 answers

Well I think they have spirits. Not to step on mandyloo's tows cause I usually agree with her. I think abortion should be illegal. The only time it should be allowed is if it in dangers the life of the mother. Then its the mothers choice. I think anyway

Answered by mandyloo on Nov 25, 2008, 02:53PM
4016 answers
Advisor-small

Your not stepping on my toes jester - I respect your opinions and beliefs. Atleast you come to the table with facts and not with lies.

Answered by colethky on Nov 25, 2008, 03:03PM
2187 answers
Advisor-small

Amblessed...

The fact remains that when you are pregnant your "baby" is called a fetus until that fetus is born.

The fact is also that a murderer can not be charged with 2 murders unless the murderer did something to directly harm the fetus (this does not include just killing the mother). If the fetus did not have any life threatening injuries and would be able to survive outside of the mother's womb then the murderer is not charged with two murders.

It is also a fact that most murderers that get charged with a double murder killed a mother and fetus in the last trimester when the fetus could survive outside of the mother's womb but was unable to because of life threatening injuries.

Back to top


Related Photos

Beach Babymy sis baby showerbaby d